Radiation Detriment Calculation Methodology

The draft Radiation Detriment Calculation Methodology is now available for public consultation. We welcome comments from individuals and organisations. The draft document can be downloaded from the ICRP website. Comments must be submitted through the ICRP website no later than June 5, 2020.

Abstract

Radiation detriment is a concept used to quantify the harmful stochastic effects of low-level radiation exposure to the human population. It is determined from lifetime risk of cancer for a set of tissues and organs taking into account their severity in terms of lethality, quality of life, and years of life lost. It also considers heritable effects. The radiation detriment is estimated as a sex- and age-averaged risk indicator for a composite reference population. This report provides a historical review of the detriment calculation methodology adopted by the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP) since Publication 26 and a detailed description of the whole computation process used in Publication 103. It clarifies data sources, risk models, computational methods and rationale for the choice of parameter values. The parameters that have the greatest influence on the radiation detriment calculation are also identified based on a series of sensitivity analyses. They include dose and dose-rate effectiveness factor (DDREF), age at exposure, sex difference and lethality fraction. Although the current scheme of radiation detriment calculation is well established, it may need to evolve to take into account changes in baseline reference data (mortality, cancer incidence and lethality) in recent decades and progress in scientific understanding of radiation health effects. In this perspective, the report suggests ways to update and improve the estimation of key parameters for the calculation of radiation detriment, such as the reference population data and cancer severity. There is also room for improvement in cancer risk models based on the accumulation of recent epidemiological findings. Finally, the importance of improving the comprehensibility of the radiation detriment concept and the transparency of its calculation methodology is emphasised.

Draft Document: Radiation Detriment Calculation Methodology


Submit your comment before: June 5, 2020
    Cancel

Comments

 Name OrganisationDate
ViewMarina Di Giorgio on behalf ofArgentine Radiation Protection Society (SAR)Thu Jun 4 15:49:22 UTC+0200 2020
ViewGraham Smithas an individualClemson University and GMS Abingdon LtdThu Jun 4 12:13:17 UTC+0200 2020
ViewBernd Lorenzon behalf ofENISSThu Jun 4 12:01:26 UTC+0200 2020
ViewYann Billarandon behalf ofIRSNThu Jun 4 11:16:27 UTC+0200 2020
ViewCynthia Folkers and Diane D'Arrigoon behalf ofBeyond Nuclear, Nuclear Information and Resource ServiceThu Jun 4 11:10:42 UTC+0200 2020
ViewLuana Hafneron behalf ofSwiss Federal Nuclear Safety Inspectorate ENSIThu Jun 4 09:23:06 UTC+0200 2020
ViewFelix Heinzlon behalf ofGerman Federal Office for Radiation Protection Thu Jun 4 09:04:35 UTC+0200 2020
ViewPaddy Gilliganon behalf ofEuroSafe ImagingThu Jun 4 08:12:01 UTC+0200 2020
ViewTeun van Dillenon behalf ofRIVM and ANVSWed Jun 3 13:39:41 UTC+0200 2020
ViewMichiya Sasakion behalf ofCRIEPI, JapanWed Jun 3 02:48:46 UTC+0200 2020
ViewAnnegret Gntheron behalf ofGlobal Research for Safety (GRS)Tue Jun 2 11:42:47 UTC+0200 2020
ViewAnna Friedlon behalf ofGerman Commission on Radiation ProtectionMon May 25 04:26:39 UTC+0200 2020
ViewAaron Datesmanas an individualUniversity of VirginiaThu May 21 15:44:42 UTC+0200 2020
ViewRoger Coatesas an individualIRPA Executive CouncilMon May 18 06:59:31 UTC+0200 2020
ViewJaiki Leeas an individualKorean Association for Radiation ProtectionMon May 11 02:54:01 UTC+0200 2020
ViewHenrichs, Klauson behalf ofGerman-Swiss Association for Radiation ProtectionWed Apr 29 09:20:55 UTC+0200 2020
ViewJozef Sabol, Dron behalf ofDepartment of Crisis Management PACR in PragueFri Apr 3 14:20:31 UTC+0200 2020
ViewAshwini Sathnuras an individualUnited Nations Development ProgrammeMon Feb 3 10:04:44 UTC+0100 2020